Middle East Eye

Subscribe to Middle East Eye feed
Updated: 2 days 17 hours ago

Silvio Berlusconi and the Middle East: Gaddafi, Iraq war and Israel

Mon, 06/12/2023 - 14:25
Silvio Berlusconi and the Middle East: Gaddafi, Iraq war and Israel
From close relations with Libya's Gaddafi to a sex scandal with an underage Moroccan dancer, the Italian leader had a controversial history with the region
Rayhan Uddin Mon, 06/12/2023 - 15:25
Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi greets Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi during a meeting in Sirte, Libya on 10 February 2004 (AFP)
Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi greets Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi during a meeting in Sirte, Libya, on 10 February 2004 (AFP)

Silvio Berlusconi, Italy's former prime minister, died on Monday aged 86.

The billionaire media mogul, and the country's longest-serving premier, built up a huge empire in media, real estate and football, before launching a political career in 1994. 

He was prime minister across three different terms between 1994 and 2011, totalling nine years in charge.

His time in office was characterised by populist policies and rhetoric, frequent gaffes and outbursts, and a number of sex scandals and allegations of wrongdoing, many of which resulted in legal proceedings.

He died in Milan after being treated in April for a lung infection linked to chronic myelomonocytic leukaemia. 

//--> //--> //-->

From cancelling a meeting with King Abdullah of Jordan to "attend a party with Vladimir Putin", to kissing the hand of Libya's Muammar Gaddafi, Berlusconi had a colourful and controversial relationship with the Middle East and North Africa during his terms in office.

He vocally supported the US-led invasion of Iraq, which he later claimed to have opposed.

He also had a notoriously close relationship with Gaddafi, but would later be part of the coalition of forces that helped to bring down the government of the late Libyan autocrat.

By far his biggest controversy related to the region involved a sex scandal with an underage Moroccan dancer who Berlusconi falsely claimed was the granddaughter of Egypt's then-president. 

Middle East Eye takes a look at some of the key moments in Berlusconi's dealings with the region.

Gaddafi

After Gaddafi took power in a 1969 coup, he repeatedly took aim at Italy over its 1911-43 repressive colonial rule of Libya. 

So when he stepped off the plane in Rome in 2009 to be greeted by Berlusconi, it was a historic visit on many levels.

//--> //--> //-->

For one, Gaddafi was accompanied by the son of Omar al-Mukhtar, a Libyan revolutionary hero who had been executed by Italian authorities in 1931 for leading the resistance movement against Italian colonial forces. 

“For us, that image is like the cross some of you wear,” Gaddafi told reporters while wearing a picture of Mukhtar being captured by Italian fascist soldiers. 

The epic Gaddafi-funded film Lion of the Desert, about Mukhtar’s life, was screened on Italian television upon the Libyan leader's visit, after having been banned since 1982 for “damaging the honour” of the Italian army.

Gaddafi also brought an entourage of 300 with him, pitching a Bedouin-style tent in a 17th-century palace in the Italian capital. 

The trip - Gaddafi's first to Rome - typified the close relationship between Berlusconi and the Libyan ruler, who had long been maligned in the West over allegations of directly and indirectly supporting terrorism. 

A year earlier, the two had agreed to a deal in which Italy would compensate Libya for the hardships of colonialism to the tune of $5bn in infrastructure projects, in return for Tripoli intercepting those trying to cross the border to Italy. 

gaddafi berlusconi airport image
Gaddafi wears a historic picture of Omar al-Muktar, the "Lion of the desert", being captured by Italian soldiers, after the North African leader's arrival at Ciampino airport in Rome, Italy, on 10 June 2009 (AFP)

//--> //--> //-->

During one meeting at the Arab League summit, Berlusconi even kissed his Libyan counterpart's hand - a gesture which sparked backlash in Italy. 

The relationship was more than just symbolic: in 2004 the two leaders inaugurated the Greenstream gas pipeline, which runs from Wafa in Libya to Sicily in Italy. It remains the longest underwater pipeline in the Mediterranean. 

At the height of the leaders' close ties, Libya’s government owned shares in Italy’s stock market and several major companies, and even owned part of the Juventus football club. Meanwhile, Libya was Italy's largest oil supplier. 

Those close ties came crashing down during the Libyan uprising of 2011 which toppled Gaddafi. 

'I have been surprised by the attitude of a friend with whom I have sealed a treaty of friendship that benefits both our nations'

- Gaddafi in a letter to Berlusconi

At first, Berlusconi claimed he could “convince him to go into exile” and negotiate “an honourable exit from the scene” for the man who ruled Libya for 42 years. 

"I'm saddened for Gaddafi and I'm sorry," Berlusconi said in March 2011. "What's happening in Libya hits me personally."

Despite his sorrow and regret, the no-fly zone imposed over Libya in 2011 was launched from Italian soil at a Nato base in Naples. It was only months earlier that Berlusconi was kissing Gaddafi’s hand. 

According to reports, Gaddafi sent a letter to Berlusconi pleading for Italy’s help in his last months. 

“I have been surprised by the attitude of a friend with whom I have sealed a treaty of friendship that benefits both our nations,” the letter read. 

“I would have hoped that at least you would have been concerned at the facts and would have attempted a mediation before adding your support to this war.”

After Gaddafi was eventually captured, killed and dragged through the streets, Berlusconi commented with the Latin phrase: "Sic transit gloria mundi" (thus passes the glory of the world). 

Support for Iraq war

Berlusconi backed the US-led invasion of Iraq in 2003, despite the majority of Italians being against it. 

He lent support to his American and British counterparts George Bush and Tony Blair, stating: “Today the West is the only military power, and within the West, there is the incomparable super military power of the United States”. 

“And today we ask if it should be possible, looking to the future, to intervene as exporters of democracy and freedom in the whole world.”

Two years earlier, he had caused international outrage among Muslim countries, following the 11 September New York attacks, when he described western civilisation as "superior".

Meloni's victory in Italy signals the rise of a global anti-Muslim alliance
Read More »

“We should be conscious of the superiority of our civilisation, which consists of a value system that has given people widespread prosperity in those countries that embrace it, and guarantees respect for human rights and religion," he said. "This respect certainly does not exist in the Islamic countries.”

Despite domestic criticism, Berlusconi impassionately defended US actions in Iraq, even citing the American defence of Europe during World War II. 

He used that defence to state that it was “unthinkable” for him to reject Bush’s request for an Italian military presence in Iraq. 

''Everyone should have the awareness of owing gratitude to the great American democracy,” he said. 

Italy did not supply troops for the initial invasion in March 2003 but sent 3,000 soldiers after the fall of Baghdad weeks later. 

In 2005, however, Berlusconi claimed that he repeatedly tried to talk Bush out of the invasion. 

"I have never been convinced war was the best way to succeed in making a country democratic and extract it from an albeit bloody dictatorship," he said. "I tried on several occasions to convince the American president not to wage war."

The remarks were ridiculed by Italy's then opposition, who saw it as a cynical re-election tactic amid poor economic conditions and backlash over his foreign policy. 

Pro-Israel stance

Berlusconi was one of the most pro-Israeli leaders in Europe during his tenure, even touting Israeli membership of the EU.

In the 1980s, the Italian government had been relatively pro-Palestinian.

Former President Sando Pertini used his end-of-year address in 1982 to talk about the murders of Palestinian refugees in Sabra and Shatila during the Lebanese civil war, while former socialist Prime Minister Bettino Craxi defended the Palestinian armed struggle in 1985. 

But Berlusconi staunchly supported Israel, describing it as “not only the biggest example of democracy and liberty in the Middle East, but the only example”.

In 2010 he said that he considered Israel to be a European country, and "dreamed" of its membership in the EU.

“As long as I am one of the shapers of politics, my greatest dream is to include Israel among the European Union countries,” he said. 

He opposed attempts for “unilateral recognition of Palestine” unless a unified Palestinian government denounced terrorism and accepted Israel’s right to exist, and vowed to fight against any such attempts in Europe.

netanyahu berlusconi
Silvio Berlusconi and his then-Israeli counterpart Benjamin Netanyahu during an Italy-Israel summit at Villa Madama in Rome, on 13 June 2011 (AFP)

He has occasionally come under criticism from some Israeli quarters too, particularly over comments related to fascism in the 1930s. 

In the European Parliament in 2003, he told a German politician that he would be “perfect” for the role of a concentration camp guard. 

He also offered praise towards fascist leader Benito Mussolini, who he once claimed “did not kill anyone”. 

Thousands of Italian Jews were deported during the Holocaust, according to data compiled by historian Liliana Picciotto Fargion, many of whom were killed in concentration camps. 

'Ruby-gate'

One of the biggest scandals during Berlusconi’s time in charge involved Moroccan dancer, Karima el-Mahroug.

Berlusconi was accused of paying to have sex with Mahroug, known by the nickname "Ruby the heartstealer", in early 2010 when she was 17 years old.

Mahroug told reporters at the time that she had been given 7,000 euros and jewellery during a dinner held by the then-prime minister at his mansion near Milan. Both Mahroug and Berlusconi denied having had sex. 

The Moroccan was later arrested at a police station in Milan after being accused of theft. 

The police officer in charge of the inquiry said that he received a call from Berlusconi, who had falsely claimed that Mahroug was the granddaughter of then-Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak. 

The mogul was convicted in 2013 and sentenced to seven years in prison and banned from public office after being charged with paying for sex with an underage woman. But the conviction was overturned upon appeal a year later, and he once again became eligible to run for office. 

So-called "bunga bunga parties", in which young dancers and models were invited to Berlusconi’s residence in Milan for wild gatherings reportedly resembling orgies, were a feature of the Italian prime minister’s personal life. 

He faced several legal cases involving the parties, on charges ranging from corruption to tax fraud and underage prostitution, but they were all either dismissed or overturned on appeal. 

Canada and Netherlands take Syria to UN's top court over torture claims

Mon, 06/12/2023 - 14:16
Canada and Netherlands take Syria to UN's top court over torture claims
The two countries accuse Syrian government of violating international law
MEE staff Mon, 06/12/2023 - 15:16
The Syrian opposition still controls some of northern Syria, areas which have been pummelled by the government (AFP)
The Syrian opposition still controls some of northern Syria, areas which have been pummelled by the government (AFP)

Canada and the Netherlands are taking Syria to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) over claims that the government of President Bashar al-Assad engaged in torture against its people.

In their application to the court, the two countries accused Syria of having committed "countless violations of international law".

"These violations include the use of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment… including through abhorrent treatment of detainees, inhumane conditions in places of detention, enforced disappearances, the use of sexual and gender-based violence, and violence against children," they said in a statement released by the ICJ.

The use of chemical weapons in the war in Syria, which began after an uprising in 2011, was also specifically mentioned in the application, described as a "particularly abhorrent practice to intimidate and punish the civilian population".

While the Syrian government has denied the use of chemical weapons, and claimed that the country's opposition used them, the government has been blamed for the use of such internationally banned weapons on several occasions, including in January by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons. 

Canada, the Netherlands and Syria are all parties to the UN Convention Against Torture. 

The ICJ will now determine whether it has the jurisdiction to hear the case. If it does decide to proceed, it is unclear when the ICJ would deliver its verdict, as the court can take years to process cases. 

Syria carried out 2018 chlorine attack on Douma, OPCW finds
Read More »

In a statement, the Dutch foreign ministry said that there was "ample evidence" that Syria had committed "serious human rights violations against Syrian citizens on a grand scale".

Along with Canada, it decided to approach the ICJ after efforts were frustrated at the UN Security Council, where Syrian ally Russia - which has been actively involved in the war - has a veto. 

The ongoing conflict has caused mass devastation to Syria and involves forces from several countries, including Turkey and Iran.

Hundreds of thousands have been killed, many of them civilians, and millions have been both internally and externally displaced, with many becoming refugees, predominantly in the Middle East and Europe. 

After opposition gains in the early years of the war, the government was able to turn the tide with Russian and Iranian backing, and opposition forces are now only in control of portions of the northern part of the country.

Israel: Opposition leader testifies at Netanyahu corruption trial

Mon, 06/12/2023 - 10:18
Israel: Opposition leader testifies at Netanyahu corruption trial
Lapid appears as prosecution's witness in 'Case 1000' in which the prime minister is accused of fraud and breach of trust
MEE staff Mon, 06/12/2023 - 11:18
Leader of Israel's Yesh Atid Party, Yair Lapid (File photo/AFP)

Israel's opposition leader testified on Monday in the corruption trial of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, which would see him removed from office if found guilty. 

Yair Lapid appeared in court as a prosecution witness in "Case 1000", in which Netanyahu is accused of granting Hollywood tycoon Arnon Milchan a tax break in return for lavish gifts. 

The Yesh Atid party chief spoke about his interactions with Netanyahu in 2013 when he served as his finance minister. 

He said he discussed the situation with the premier on two occasions.  

"The first time [we met] Netanyahu said to me, 'Did Milchan speak with you about the law?' I told him yes, and he asked, 'What do you think?' I told him, 'I'm not so sure about it,' and he said, [that it's a] 'Good law.'

"The second time was the same when Netanyahu asked what was going on [with it], and I said that it's not going to happen, and he again repeated that [it's a] 'good law'," Lapid said.

Netanyahu was charged in 2019 with bribery, fraud and breach of trust in three cases dubbed Case 1000, Case 2000 and Case 4000. He denies all wrongdoing. 

In Case 1000, he is accused of allegedly receiving 700,000 shekels ($195,000) worth of gifts given to his wife Sara from Milchan, a famed Israeli Hollywood producer and Academy Award nominee, and Australian businessman James Packer. 

Netanyahu, who is Israel's longest-serving leader, says the exchanges of gifts were friendly gestures. 

Since returning as prime minister late last year, Netanyahu's new government - described as the most right wing in the country's history - has embarked on a judicial reform programme which critics say could help him evade conviction or see his case dismissed. The prime minister dismissed such suggestions and said he would not intervene in legal proceedings. 

The 2019 corruption charges have overshadowed the Israeli political scene and sent the country to the polls five times in less than four years. Each vote has become a de-facto referendum on Netanyahu's fitness to rule. 

After losing to a coalition of opponents in 2021, Netanyahu returned to office in December. 

Under Israeli law, the prime minister has no obligation to step aside while on trial.

The trial, which has been ongoing since May 2020, has featured more than 40 prosecution witnesses, including some of Netanyahu's closest former confidants who turned against him. Witness accounts have shed light not only on the three cases, but also revealed sensational details about Netanyahu's character and his family's reputation for living off the largesse of taxpayers and wealthy supporters.

According to the current court schedule, the trial is expected to last for another five years.

Israeli opposition leader testifies at Netanyahu corruption trial

Turkey: Istanbul animal welfare chief jailed for running cock-fighting ring

Mon, 06/12/2023 - 08:56
Turkey: Istanbul animal welfare chief jailed for running cock-fighting ring
Head of Istanbul Association for the Protection of Animals, the Environment and Nature imprisoned for three years despite claiming there was no mistreatment in his garage
Alex MacDonald Mon, 06/12/2023 - 09:56
Turkish police reportedly received a tip off about an illegal cock-fighting ring (AFP/file photo)
Turkish police reportedly received a tip off about an illegal cock-fighting ring (AFP/file photo)

The man appointed to oversee the welfare of animals in Istanbul has reportedly been imprisoned for overseeing a cock-fighting ring.

Turkish police received a tip-off about an illegal cock-fighting ring in a garage in Istanbul's Sancaktepe district, local media said.

After raiding it on 24 January, they found a ring made for roosters with seating around it. On the floor were animal hair, traces of blood and bottles of alcohol.

According to the Sabah newspaper, the owner of the garage was Ufuk Inanc, head of the Istanbul Association for the Protection of Animals, the Environment and Nature.

Inanc has denied that the garage was being used for cock-fighting and instead said it was used for the activities of his association.

"As the president of the association, I would not allow such a thing, it is against our founding purpose," he said.

Another suspect present at the scene was quoted by Sabah as saying the caged roosters found in the garage were being auctioned and had not been injured. However, investigators reportedly found blood stains and rooster feathers within the ring.

Despite his protestations, Inanc has been sentenced to three years in prison for "providing a place and opportunity for gambling", while three other suspects were sentenced to up to two years in prison for "violating the Law on the Protection of Animals".

Law against animal abuse

The raid reportedly came a few days after another on a branch of the association in the western city of Manisa, also connected with cock fighting.

The Sozcu newspaper said police had raided the Manisa Animals, Environment and Nature Protection Association on 22 January and found 21 injured roosters and a specially prepared area for fighting

Turkey's parliament passed a law in 2021 that made animal abuse punishable by between six months and four years in prison.

However, animal rights campaigners have criticised the law as insufficient, noting that judges usually defer prison sentences less than two years, meaning few convicted of animal abuse would actually face jail time.

This article is available in French on Middle East Eye French edition.

Istanbul animal welfare chief jailed for running cock-fighting ring

Pages